Fair Housing Act: What Every Landlord Needs to Know

If you own a rental in South Carolina, the Fair Housing Act applies to you more often than you’d guess. Most owners know discrimination is illegal. Fewer realize a listing, a quick text, or an instruction to a manager can break the rule before a single person applies. This post is for owners who want the bigger picture of landlord-tenant law in South Carolina explained in plain English, starting with fair housing, since it’s the area where honest mistakes cost the most.

We’ll cover who’s protected, who’s exempt (fewer people than you think), where owners trip up in ads and screening, and how assistance animals and disability requests work. We’re a property management company, not a law firm, so treat this as a working landlord’s guide and not legal advice.

7
protected classes under federal law
100
homes we manage
4.5 yrs
average resident stay with us
20
years in business

In This Guide

1Who the Fair Housing Act Protects2The Exemptions Are Narrower Than Most Owners Think3Advertising Is Where Owners Trip First4Screening Every Applicant the Same Way5Families With Children and the Wear-and-Tear Worry6Service Animals, ESAs, and No-Pets Policies7Disability Accommodations and Modifications8Why Student Season Raises the Stakes in Columbia9What Happens When Someone Files a Complaint10Putting It Together

Who the Fair Housing Act Protects

Federal law bars discrimination in renting based on seven characteristics:

7
protected classes under federal law

“Federal law bars discrimination in renting based on seven characteristics”

  • Race
  • Color
  • National origin
  • Religion
  • Sex
  • Familial status
  • Disability

South Carolina’s own Fair Housing Law covers the same ground, listing disability under the term “handicap.” It’s enforced by the South Carolina Human Affairs Commission. Some cities add extra protected classes through local ordinances. We haven’t confirmed that any local rule here does, so check before you assume the list stops at seven.

The law reaches more than a flat “no.” You can’t refuse to rent, refuse to negotiate, or make a home unavailable because of a protected class. You also can’t offer different terms, conditions, services, or privileges. Quoting one applicant a higher deposit than another because of a protected class, for example, counts.

The Exemptions Are Narrower Than Most Owners Think

Plenty of private landlords believe they’re exempt. Sometimes that’s true. Usually it isn’t.

Federal and state law both carve out two situations:

  1. An owner-occupied building with up to four units.
  2. A private owner of no more than three single-family houses, who rents without a broker, agent, or property manager and without a discriminatory ad.

Look at the fine print in that second one. Hire a property manager and the exemption is gone. Own a dwelling for five or more families, or handle several rental or sale deals in a year, and you’re treated as being in the rental business.

And no exemption ever covers discriminatory advertising. Even a landlord with a duplex they live in can’t post an ad that shows a preference.

Key takeaway

Don’t count on being exempt. If you use a manager, own more than a few homes, or advertise at all, assume the rules apply to you.

Advertising Is Where Owners Trip First

Most owners picture fair housing trouble at the rejection stage. We’d argue the risk often starts earlier, in the listing. Federal and state law ban any ad or statement that shows a preference, limitation, or discrimination based on a protected class. That includes the well-meaning kind.

Here’s how casual wording goes wrong:

Risky phraseWhy it’s a problemSafer approach
“Perfect for singles” or “ideal for young professionals”Signals families aren’t wantedDescribe the home: bedrooms, layout, parking
“No kids” or “quiet adult community”Excludes families with childrenDescribe noise or quiet hours in the lease, not who lives there
“Walking distance to churches”Can steer by religionName the actual amenities: grocery, bus line, park
“Great for couples”Signals a household preferenceList square footage and features

Say an owner posts “ideal for young professionals” because it sounds upbeat. Nobody has applied yet, and that owner may already have a problem.

The fix is easy. Write about the property, never the person you imagine living in it. That goes for student housing too. “Furnished, near campus, utilities listed” describes a home. “Perfect for college guys” describes a preference.

Watch out

A discriminatory ad is a violation even if no one applies and even if you’d otherwise be exempt. Penalties can be steep and the amounts adjust over time, so check the current figures before you assume the cost is small.

Screening Every Applicant the Same Way

Fair housing complaints often come down to one question: did you hold everyone to the same standard? If you can’t show that, you’re relying on your memory against someone’s version of events.

The cure is boring and effective. Decide your criteria before you list, write them down, and apply them to every application. Typical items include:

  • Income: a minimum, usually a multiple of monthly rent
  • Credit: what range you’ll accept and how you treat past collections
  • Rental history: prior landlord references and any evictions
  • Occupancy: a household limit tied to the size of the unit
  • Application timing: first complete application that meets criteria gets the unit

Then follow it even when you like one applicant better. Making an exception for the person you “just have a good feeling about” is how a pattern starts.

You can still say no to someone who poses a real and present threat of substantial harm to others or to the property. State law allows that. It has to rest on facts about that person, not a guess about a group. How you handle criminal history is a separate and tricky question, so talk to an attorney before you build a rule around it.

We show every property ourselves. We don’t do self-guided tours. That’s partly about placing people we’d trust in our own homes, but it also means the process is the same for every prospect who walks through the door.

This worksheet helps you write down your screening standards before you list so you can hold every application to the same criteria.

Free worksheet

Written screening criteria worksheet

Write your screening standards down before you list, then hold every application to them. Apply the same written criteria to every applicant.

Download the PDF

0 of 12 filled in

Income and credit

Rental history and background

How you decide

Tips

  • Publish your criteria with the listing, so applicants know what to expect before they pay a fee.
  • Never ask about or act on race, color, religion, sex, national origin, familial status or disability. Many places also protect source of income and other groups, so check your state and local rules.
  • Keep a short note on each decision, tied to the criteria, so you can explain any yes or no later.
  • Check your state and local rules on application fees, credit checks, eviction records and criminal history before you finalize the list, and review it once a year.

Your entries stay in this browser only.

Families With Children and the Wear-and-Tear Worry

Familial status is the protection that surprises owners most. In South Carolina it covers households with children under 18 living with a parent, a legal custodian, or their written designee. It also covers anyone who is pregnant or in the process of getting legal custody of a child.

Picture an owner who tells their manager, “No families with kids, they wreck everything.” Worry about damage feels reasonable to the owner. It’s still textbook discrimination, and a manager who follows that instruction shares the exposure. We’re committed to treating every applicant fairly, so that’s an instruction we’d push back on.

Wear and tear is a real concern, but you handle it through the deposit, the lease, and move-in inspections. You can’t handle it by excluding a class of people.

One narrow exception exists. Housing for older persons can limit by age, but only if it truly qualifies:

  • Housing run under a qualifying government program
  • Housing for people 62 or older only
  • 55+ housing where at least 80% of units have an occupant 55 or older, and the owner publishes and follows age policies

Calling a building “adult” doesn’t qualify it. Calling it “55+” without meeting the test doesn’t either.

Service Animals, ESAs, and No-Pets Policies

Owners like clean rules, and “no pets, period” sounds clean. It’s incomplete.

assistance animals aren’t pets under fair housing law. So a no-pets policy can’t be applied to a tenant who needs one. Say a landlord with a strict no-pets rule gets an application from someone with a documented emotional support animal. Denying that application over the animal alone could trigger a discrimination complaint.

Our own approach is simple. Owners decide whether pets are allowed at their property, and for approved pets we require a deposit and a monthly pet fee. We screen applicants and pets. But service animal and ESA compliance isn’t up to owner preference. We follow federal and state fair housing law, and that part isn’t negotiable.

You may have heard that federal policy on assistance animals has shifted. The South Carolina Human Affairs Commission has told landlords not to change their accommodation practices because of that. State law doesn’t require the animal to be individually trained. The questions are whether the person has a disability and a disability-related need for the animal’s help or emotional support. The Commission also warns that revoking an accommodation you’ve already granted carries its own liability risk.

If an assistance animal request lands on your desk, slow down and get advice before you answer.

Disability Accommodations and Modifications

Two different requests fall under disability protection, and owners mix them up.

Reasonable accommodations

This is a change to a rule, policy, or service. An assistance animal exception is the best-known example. Refusing a reasonable accommodation is itself discrimination.

Reasonable modifications

This is a physical change to the unit, like a grab bar or a ramp. The tenant pays for it. For a rental, you can generally require the tenant to agree to restore the interior when they leave, except for reasonable wear and tear.

Owners often assume they must pay for these changes in a private rental. The statutes put the cost on the tenant. Newer multifamily buildings, those first occupied after March 13, 1991 with four or more units, have separate accessible design rules that apply to construction.

Why Student Season Raises the Stakes in Columbia

USC enrollment tops 35,000, so Columbia property rentals turn over fast, and a lot of screening happens in a short stretch. Move-ins crowd into late July and August. Applications pile up, owners want units filled, and shortcuts start to look tempting.

That’s exactly when fair housing mistakes happen. A rushed “I’ll take the first person who seems easy” decision, with no written criteria behind it, is hard to defend later.

The mix of renters here adds to it. Fort Jackson is nearby, so military families are common. Graduate students with kids, and households relocating for healthcare or state government jobs, add more families. Familial status and disability requests aren’t rare edge cases around here. They come up regularly.

What Happens When Someone Files a Complaint

Tenants and applicants in South Carolina can file with the South Carolina Human Affairs Commission. It costs nothing and doesn’t require an attorney. Federal complaints and private lawsuits are also available, and each has its own deadlines, so check the current ones if you’re ever on the receiving end.

A complaint can mean an investigation, document requests, legal fees, and hours of your time, even if you did nothing wrong. The best defense is a paper trail:

  • Your written screening criteria, applied to every applicant
  • Dated records of applications received and decisions made
  • Copies of your ads
  • Written notes on any accommodation request and how you responded

This is why many private landlords in Columbia, SC hand screening and advertising to a licensed manager. Owners who live out of state, which we handle a lot of, can’t watch every showing. A written, consistent process matters even more for them.

A manager doesn’t erase your liability, though. You still need to know the rules your manager is following. Andrea Hampton, one of our clients, wrote that she’s “had the best experience with my rental property being managed by superior rental properties.” A good property manager follows a process that treats every applicant fairly while protecting the owner’s investment.

Putting It Together

Fair housing compliance mostly comes down to habits:

  1. Write ads about the property, not the person.
  2. Write your screening criteria before you list.
  3. Apply them to every applicant, every time.
  4. Treat assistance animal and accommodation requests as legal questions, not preferences.
  5. Keep records.

Property management in Columbia, SC means making these calls constantly. We’ve owned rentals ourselves for a long time and have managed other owners’ homes for 20 years, so we know how tempting shortcuts look in a busy August. If fair housing rules feel harder to follow than they should, we’re open to a conversation.

FAQ

Does the Fair Housing Act apply if I only own one rental?

Possibly not, but don’t count on it. A private owner of up to three single-family houses can be exempt only if they rent without a broker, agent, or property manager and without a discriminatory ad. Hiring a manager ends the exemption, and the advertising rule always applies.

Can I refuse to rent to families with children in an adults-only building?

Only if the building qualifies as housing for older persons, meaning a qualifying government program, 62+ housing, or 55+ housing meeting the 80% occupancy test with published age policies. Calling a building “adult” doesn’t make it exempt.

Can I say no pets and still turn down an assistance animal?

No. Assistance animals aren’t pets under fair housing law. In South Carolina the animal doesn’t have to be individually trained. The questions are whether the person has a disability and a disability-related need for the animal’s help or emotional support. Get advice before you respond to a request.

Who pays for a modification a tenant with a disability needs?

The tenant does, under the statutes. For a rental, you can generally require the tenant to agree to restore the interior when they leave, except for reasonable wear and tear.

Where does a tenant file a fair housing complaint in South Carolina?

With the South Carolina Human Affairs Commission. Filing is free and doesn’t need an attorney. The number is 1-800-521-0725 or (803) 737-7800, and complaints can be filed at schac.sc.gov/filing-complaint.

Can I deny an applicant who seems like a safety risk?

State law lets you deny or limit a rental to someone who poses a real and present threat of substantial harm to themselves, others, or the housing. It has to rest on facts about that person, not assumptions about a group, so document your reasoning.

Share the Post:

Related Posts